Saturday, March 1, 2008

CAN YOU AVOID A PERSONAL GUARANTY BY SIGNING AS AN OFFICER?

Luxury Homes and Estates of Florida

In my practice I am often given the task of collecting delinquent accounts. One of my first priorities is to review any credit application and personal guarantees signed by the debtor corporation and its officers. A common trick is that an officer signs the credit application on behalf of the corporation and then attempts to avoid liability under the personal guaranty by signing as a corporate representative.

In other words, a clear cut personal guaranty will be executed as follows “John Smith-President of XYZ”.

Such a maneuver by a creative debtor is not uncommon. However, the courts do not allow a corporate officer to escape personal liability merely by affixing his title to the signature block on the personal guaranty.

The courts review the document to determine whether or not the guaranty is unambiguous. If the guaranty states that the signer is “personally” liable or guarantees the debt no further interpretation of the document is permitted and the document is a guaranty as a matter of law.

Simply signing the signature block and inserting an officer’s title cannot defeat the purpose of the guaranty. See Central National Bank of Miami v. Muskat Corp. of America, Inc., 430 So.2d 957 (Fla. 3rd DCA 1983); Nelson v. Ameriquest Technologies, Inc., 739 So.2d 161 (Fla. 3rd DCA 1999); Sabin v. Lowe’s of Florida, Inc., 404 So.2d 772 (Fla 5th DCA 1981).

The courts enforce guarantees. To hold otherwise would merely have a corporation guaranteeing its own debt which renders the guaranty a nullity. The law is not a fool!

Visit our website for more information on this subject.

Houston Short grew up in the Central Florida area, and continues to reside in Orlando with his family. He provides representation in arbitration actions for the American Arbitration Association and engages in alternative dispute resolutions including mediation both binding and non-binding arbitration, and settlement negotiations. He is an active member of the American Arbitration Association Panel Review Committee, the Orange County Bar Association, and the Florida Bar. He graduated from Florida State University in 1984 with a bachelors of science degree (cum laude) and received his juris doctor from the University of Florida in 1987 (with honors). Houston co-authored, "The Constitutionality of the Legislatures Mandate to Sever Counterclaims in Mortgage Foreclosure Action," the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section, The Florida Bar.

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

ELECTRONIC SIGNATURES HAVE THE SAME FORCE AND EFFECT AS WRITTEN SIGNATURES

Luxury Homes and Estates of Florida

In a paperless environment parties often execute contracts and submit governmental paperwork via the internet and other electronic media. Original signatures gave way to faxed signatures and now electronic signatures are an accepted method of execution. The “Government Paperwork Elimination Act” (“GPEA”) was signed into law on October 21, 1998. The GPEA requires federal agencies, by 2003, to allow individuals or entities that deal with the agencies the option to submit information or transact with the agency electronically. The GPEA specifically states that electronic records and their related electronic signatures are not to be denied legal effect, validity or enforceability merely because they are in electronic form. Florida followed suit. The Florida Electronic Signature Act of 1996 and Uniform Electronic Transfer Act (codified in Chapter 668, Florida Statutes) (collectively “Acts”) provide that unless otherwise provided by law, an electronic signature may be used to sign a writing and shall have the same force and effect as a written signature. The Acts further provide, similar to GPEA, that a record, signature, or a contract may not be denied legal effect or enforceability solely because the record, signature or contract is in electronic form. Note, however, that all parties involved in the transaction must agree to conduct the transaction by electronic means in order for the Acts to apply.

Florida government agencies are empowered to determine whether and to what extent they will send and accept electronic records and signatures. See Florida Statute 668.50(18)(a). Further, both the Florida Statutes and the Federal Statutes provide that the type of electronic signature required and the manner and format in which electronic records and signatures must be transmitted are to be determined on an agency-by-agency basis.

Visit our website for more information on this subject.

Houston Short grew up in the Central Florida area, and continues to reside in Orlando with his family. He provides representation in arbitration actions for the American Arbitration Association and engages in alternative dispute resolutions including mediation both binding and non-binding arbitration, and settlement negotiations. He is an active member of the American Arbitration Association Panel Review Committee, the Orange County Bar Association, and the Florida Bar. He graduated from Florida State University in 1984 with a bachelors of science degree (cum laude) and received his juris doctor from the University of Florida in 1987 (with honors). Houston co-authored, "The Constitutionality of the Legislatures Mandate to Sever Counterclaims in Mortgage Foreclosure Action," the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section, The Florida Bar.

CORPORATIONS: NOT A LICENSE TO STEAL

Luxury Homes and Estates of Florida

Florida, as well as other states created by statute, corporate entities to shield owners from personal liability in order to promote trade and commerce. Ordinarily a shareholder will not be responsible for the debts of a corporation absent a guaranty to the corporate creditor. However, in certain circumstances the courts will allow a creditor to pierce the corporate veil and recover against individual shareholders.

The Florida Supreme Court established that in order to pierce the corporate veil there must be a showing of “improper conduct”. *Dania Jai-Alai Palace, Inc. v. Sykes, 450 So.2d, 1114, 1121 (Fla. 1984). It appears from Dania that the required showing is a two-step process: (1) alter ego, together with (2) some form of misconduct, which may be shown in a number of ways, including depletion of corporate assets for personal shareholder benefits or diversion of corporate property into the hands of shareholders.

The facts in Advertects involved shareholders who habitually operated numerous unsuccessful corporations; were the sole shareholders; and handled business affairs poorly. There the court refused to pierce the corporate veil because there was no showing that the shareholders improperly converted any of the corporate property to their own use or abused their positions. Thus, being a poor businessman and having a failed business does not subject one to personal liability. However, the facts in Walton v. Tomax Corp., 632 So.2d 178, 180 (Fla. 5th DCA 1994) achieved a different result. In that case, a fellow named Maguire was the manager of Tomax Corp. and his wife was the sole shareholder. A customer paid Tomax Corp. $20,000 as a deposit to construct a home. Maguire accepted deposit, never contacted the Plaintiff again, and a few months later filed for bankruptcy. The court found that the corporation could not pay its debts when the deposit was paid and that Maguire caused his company to make inappropriate distributions to himself and to his wife at the expense of corporate creditors. The court allowed an action to pierce the corporate veil and stated:

If a corporate officer who is in control of a corporation personally utilizes its assets for payment of personal obligations and generally treats the corporation as a sham, he can be liable on an alter ego theory.

The lessons in the cases are obvious. Establishing a corporation is not a license to steal. The corporate assets must be utilized for legitimate corporate purposes and not consumed or depleted for a shareholder’s personal gain.


*The Dania court relied, in part, on Advertects, Inc. v. Sawyer Industries, Inc.: “[Advertects] We rejected the proposition that a rule could be issued against individual stockholders to show cause why they should not be personally responsible for corporate debts absent a preliminary showing that the corporation is in actuality the alter ego of the stockholders and that it was organized or after organization was employed by the stockholders for fraudulent or misleading purposes, or in some fashion that the corporate property was converted assets depleted for the personal benefit of the individual stockholders, or that the corporate structure was not bona fidely established or, in general, the property belonging to the corporation can be traced into the hands of the stockholders.

Visit our website for more information on this subject.

Houston Short grew up in the Central Florida area, and continues to reside in Orlando with his family. He provides representation in arbitration actions for the American Arbitration Association and engages in alternative dispute resolutions including mediation both binding and non-binding arbitration, and settlement negotiations. He is an active member of the American Arbitration Association Panel Review Committee, the Orange County Bar Association, and the Florida Bar. He graduated from Florida State University in 1984 with a bachelors of science degree (cum laude) and received his juris doctor from the University of Florida in 1987 (with honors). Houston co-authored, "The Constitutionality of the Legislatures Mandate to Sever Counterclaims in Mortgage Foreclosure Action," the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section, The Florida Bar.

Sunday, April 1, 2007

USURY: THE PITFALLS OF CHARGING TOO MUCH INTEREST

Luxury Homes and Estates of Florida, April 2007

In the recent heated real estate environment, buyers went to great lengths to purchase property with the intent to flip same and make incredible profits. Often, the speculators were over extended and needed additional funds from friends and family members. Loans were secured with promises of quick and exorbitant returns.

Many times promissory notes were prepared by the individual without the aid of an attorney due to time constraints or merely to save money. A recent spat of these homespun promissory notes is now hitting the court system and with disastrous results to the lender.

Private lenders must be aware of Florida Statutes governing usury. Pursuant to Florida Statute 687.03, it is unlawful for a person to collect or attempt to collect interest on any obligation at a higher rate of interest than the equivalent of 18% per annum simple interest.

Pursuant to Florida Statute 687.04, any person who charged and collected usurious interest shall forfeit double the amount of interest paid.

In other words, not only are you not to collect usurious interest pursuant to the statute, as a penalty you will be required to pay double the amount of interest that you have received.

In the event that the lender seeks to enforce a promissory note that is usurious a defense or counterclaim may be received based on usury. The only amount of money that may be recovered is the actual principal sum loaned. *Further, the court may require that the principal be reduced by all interest paid pursuant to the statute.

*If the interest that you have charged exceeds 25% of the loan value you may be subject to enhanced penalties under Florida law.

Visit our website for more information on this subject.


Houston Short grew up in the Central Florida area, and continues to reside in Orlando with his family. He provides representation in arbitration actions for the American Arbitration Association and engages in alternative dispute resolutions including mediation both binding and non-binding arbitration, and settlement negotiations. He is an active member of the American Arbitration Association Panel Review Committee, the Orange County Bar Association, and the Florida Bar. He graduated from Florida State University in 1984 with a bachelors of science degree (cum laude) and received his juris doctor from the University of Florida in 1987 (with honors). Houston co-authored, "The Constitutionality of the Legislatures Mandate to Sever Counterclaims in Mortgage Foreclosure Action," the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section, The Florida Bar.

Monday, January 1, 2007

THE NAKED PROMISE TO BUY A HOME IS ENFORCEABLE

Luxury Homes and Estates of Florida,

There appears to be a misconception that a deposit must be made by a buyer of real estate to seal the deal. The Standard Contract for Sale and Purchase often requires a deposit be paid, however, the failure of the buyer to deliver the deposit does not render the contract unenforceable.

On the contrary, in the case of Peterson Homes, Inc. v. Johnson, 691 So.2d 563 (Fla. 5th DCA 1997) the court ruled that the promise to purchase property creates a binding contract even though the purchaser has paid no earnest money deposit.

In Peterson Homes, the buyer signed a contract to purchase a home for $1.1 million. The buyer was required to pay a $600,000 deposit into escrow. Peterson Homes accepted the contract, however, the buyer neither paid the deposit nor attended the closing.

Peterson Homes filed suit and claimed breach of contract.

The trial court denied the claim on the grounds that the contract lacked consideration because the buyer failed to deliver the deposit.

Evidently the trial court reasoned that a buyer can sign a contract and elect not to deliver the deposit which effectively voids same.

The 5th DCA made short shrift of this argument. No part of the contract required that the earnest money deposited be paid at the time the agreement was signed. Therefore, the contract was not contingent upon the delivery of the deposit.

A signature on a contract is all that is required to have a legal and binding promise to purchase.

Visit our website for more information on this subject.

Houston Short grew up in the Central Florida area, and continues to reside in Orlando with his family. He provides representation in arbitration actions for the American Arbitration Association and engages in alternative dispute resolutions including mediation both binding and non-binding arbitration, and settlement negotiations. He is an active member of the American Arbitration Association Panel Review Committee, the Orange County Bar Association, and the Florida Bar. He graduated from Florida State University in 1984 with a bachelors of science degree (cum laude) and received his juris doctor from the University of Florida in 1987 (with honors). Houston co-authored, "The Constitutionality of the Legislatures Mandate to Sever Counterclaims in Mortgage Foreclosure Action," the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section, The Florida Bar.

Friday, December 1, 2006

MARKETABLE RECORD TITLE ACT: THE CLOCK MAY BE TICKING AGAINST HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS

Luxury Homes and Estates of Florida,

Real property in Florida is subject to the Marketable Record Title Act*. This Act is designed to remove encumbrances against property in order to promote free and clear alienability of property. The Act generally applies to remove clouds from title which have not been re-recorded for thirty years.

In other words, if a document was recorded effecting the property over thirty years ago the Act may remove the claim from your title completely.

A core concern of the Marketable Record Title Act is that there be no hidden interest in property that could later be asserted against the property owner. See Blanton v. City of Pinellas Park, 887 So.2d 1224, 1232 (Fla. 2004).

The Marketable Record Title Act can extinguish homeowners’ covenants and restrictions if same have been abandoned and not re-recorded in the thirty year timeframe. The failure to preserve by re-recording can be fatal to homeowners associations covenants and restrictions. See Berger v. Riverwind Parking, LLP, 842 So.2d 918, 922 (Fla. 5th DCA 2000).

Homeowners associations are permitted to preserve their covenants and restrictions by recording a statement of the homeowners association’s claim pursuant to 712.06 of the Florida Statutes. H&F Land, Inc. Panama City-Bay County Airport and Industrial District 736 So.2d 1167 (Fla. 1999). The legislature adopted the statutory notice mechanism to preserve covenants and restrictions in 1997. Before that date homeowners associations routinely filed amendments, restatements and consolidations of the covenants and restrictions all designed to give notice in the chain of title in order to safeguard the restrictions from extinction.

Accordingly, each homeowners association must record it or lose it.

*Chapter 712 of the Florida Statutes.

Visit our website for more information on this subject.

Houston Short grew up in the Central Florida area, and continues to reside in Orlando with his family. He provides representation in arbitration actions for the American Arbitration Association and engages in alternative dispute resolutions including mediation both binding and non-binding arbitration, and settlement negotiations. He is an active member of the American Arbitration Association Panel Review Committee, the Orange County Bar Association, and the Florida Bar. He graduated from Florida State University in 1984 with a bachelors of science degree (cum laude) and received his juris doctor from the University of Florida in 1987 (with honors). Houston co-authored, "The Constitutionality of the Legislatures Mandate to Sever Counterclaims in Mortgage Foreclosure Action," the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section, The Florida Bar.

Wednesday, November 1, 2006

LIS PENDENS ARE NOT NECESSARILY FREE

Luxury Homes and Estates in Florida, November 2006

A lis pendens is a recorded document describing real property that provides notice to all the world of a dispute. In a purchase and sale contract a buyer will often retain the right to sue for specific performance. In the event a contract turns sour the buyer may file a lawsuit to force the sale of the property. A lis pendens is recorded in order to prevent the seller from transferring the property to a third party and thereby avoiding the jilted buyer’s claim.

Fairness requires that a bond be posted to protect the interests of a seller. The lis pendens places a red-flag in the chain of title and limits the marketability of the property. The practical effects of the lis pendens is that the owner oftentimes cannot sell or mortgage the property. If the proponent of a lis pendens turns out to not have had a valid claim the adverse economic consequences to the seller are obvious.

The Supreme Court of Florida has ruled that in circumstances where a lis pendens is recorded against property that is not related to a recorded interest (i.e., a deed or lien), the trial court has discretion to require a bond to serve as protection against damages arising from an unjustified lis pendens*. Although the court retains discretion a bond is likely wherein the facts are thin. The court will schedule an evidentiary hearing to learn all the potential damages. The type of damages that the bond should protect against include, but are not limited to, the seller’s attorney’s fees, mortgage carry expense, property taxes, insurance, and erosion in sale price.

A buyer seeking to tie up the property with a lis pendens may be asked to put his money where his mouth is.

Simple fairness requires that if you deprive a seller of the right to sell the property you should compensate the seller in the event the buyer ultimately loses the case.

Before the Supreme Court’s announcement some districts in Florida thought it mandatory to post a bond. In other jurisdictions the courts deemed the trial court to have discretion but also required that the seller prove irreparable harm.

The Supreme Court removes any doubt: (1) the court retains discretion to require a bond; and (2) the seller need not show irreparable harm but merely demonstrate damages will likely flow from the cloud on title.

*The Supreme Court case is Medical Facilities Development, Inc. v. Little Arch Creek Properties, Inc., 675 So.2d 915 (Fla. 1996).

Visit our website for more information on this subject.


Houston Short grew up in the Central Florida area, and continues to reside in Orlando with his family. He provides representation in arbitration actions for the American Arbitration Association and engages in alternative dispute resolutions including mediation both binding and non-binding arbitration, and settlement negotiations. He is an active member of the American Arbitration Association Panel Review Committee, the Orange County Bar Association, and the Florida Bar. He graduated from Florida State University in 1984 with a bachelors of science degree (cum laude) and received his juris doctor from the University of Florida in 1987 (with honors). Houston co-authored, "The Constitutionality of the Legislatures Mandate to Sever Counterclaims in Mortgage Foreclosure Action," the Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Section, The Florida Bar.